🌒 When It’s Dark and I’m Alone (and Questioning My Life Choices)

There’s something about October nights that makes me want to rewatch every questionable horror movie from the 80s, 90s, and early 2000s — the ones with too much fake blood, over-the-top acting, and plots that make absolutely no sense but still feel like home.

Did you go through a horror-movie phase where that’s all you watched? Because same. My mom not-so-gleefully sat through it all (sorry, Mom), while my dad happily grabbed popcorn and pretended he wasn’t scared. The rule was simple: too much sexy time = turn it off. Which meant Urban Legend didn’t make the cut until I was older.

Even though there are newer horror movies with better effects, I still lean back into the ones I grew up on — the sleepover staples, the VHS rentals, the ones that make me laugh and cringe at the same time. They’re not the scariest, but they’re mine.

🧠 Standalone, Cult & Comfort Favorites

When you want something creepy, nostalgic, or just plain weird — without the sleepless-night regret. These are the one-offs, comfort watches, and cult classics that define my spooky season.

• Practical Magic (1998) — The official start of spooky season in my house. Wine, witches, and sisterhood — perfection.
• The Craft (1996) — Witchy rebellion, 90s angst, and the plaid skirts we all wanted.
• Joy Ride (2001) — Don’t talk to strangers on a CB radio. You’ve been warned.
• Ginger Snaps (2000) — Puberty, sisterhood, and werewolves — moody and beautifully weird.
• The Faculty (1998) — Teen aliens, 90s soundtracks, and Elijah Wood saving the world.
• Disturbing Behavior (1998) — Brainwashing, flannel, and small-town weirdness.
• Tremors (1990) — Sandworms, sarcasm, and small-town panic.
• Thir13en Ghosts (2001) — Haunted-house eye candy with bonus panic attacks.
• The Mist (2007) — Monsters, fog, and a gut-punch ending you’ll never forgive.
• From Dusk Till Dawn (1996) — Bank robbers meet vampires. It shouldn’t work, but it does.
• Idle Hands (1999) — Possessed hand, stoner comedy, and peak 90s chaos.
• An American Werewolf in Paris (1997) — Bad CGI, great vibes, pure nostalgia.
• Valentine (2001) — Roses are red, the killer wears a mask, and I love every second.
• Dracula 2000 (2000) — Goth panic meets Y2K energy. Gerard Butler with fangs? Yes.
• Van Helsing (2004) — Hugh Jackman vs. every monster in existence. Absurdly fun.
• The Skeleton Key (2005) — Southern-gothic mystery with a twist that still hits hard.
• Carrie (2013) — The modern revenge we didn’t know we needed. Controversial? Maybe. Worth it? Absolutely.
• Beetlejuice (1988) — Ghostly chaos and peak Tim Burton weirdness.
• The Addams Family (1991) — Macabre, stylish, and wholesomely twisted.
• Edward Scissorhands (1990) — Melancholy, magic, and suburbia’s soft-goth fever dream.
• Interview with the Vampire (1994) — Velvet, fangs, and existential dread.
• Hocus Pocus (1993 / 2022) — The definition of cozy Halloween nostalgia.
• Shaun of the Dead (2004) — Zombies, sarcasm, and toast.
• Mars Attacks! (1996) — Sci-fi camp at its finest.
• Independence Day (1996) — Technically action, but tell me you weren’t scared.
• The Lost Boys (1987) — Vampires, eyeliner, eternal cool.
• American Psycho (2000) — Stylish, scary, and uncomfortably relevant.

🔪 Horror Series & Franchises to Binge

Because sometimes one movie isn’t enough — you need six versions of the same bad decision just to feel complete. These are the series I come back to every fall when I want nostalgia, chaos, and that specific 2000s horror energy.

• Scream Series — Clever, funny, and full of people doing exactly what they shouldn’t. The originals are 90s perfection; the new ones are gloriously ridiculous in all the right ways.
• I Know What You Did Last Summer — Teen drama wrapped in horror. Everyone’s beautiful, suspicious, and running in heels.
• Halloween Series — Jamie Lee Curtis is Halloween. Every time she returns, it feels like catching up with an old friend who’s just exhausted by life.
• Friday the 13th — Classic camp chaos. If you hear a sound in the woods… don’t.
• The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (2003) — The Jessica Biel one. Gritty, sweaty, terrifying perfection.
• Final Destination Series — The franchise that made us all afraid of roller coasters, highways, and dental cleanings. Bloodlines (2025) is cheesy and wonderful in the best possible way.
• Jeepers Creepers — Creepy roads, 2000s jump scares, and backwoods nightmares.
• Urban Legend — College horror meets killer fashion. Pure 90s chaos.
• House of 1000 Corpses / The Devil’s Rejects — Rob Zombie’s loud, grimy, gloriously weird horror world.
• Scary Movie Series — The perfect reset button when you’ve overdone the actual scares. Dumb, over the top, and exactly what you need.
• Blade Trilogy — Stylish vampires, techno beats, and trench coats that could cut glass.
• Underworld Series — Vampires vs. werewolves, but make it sexy, goth, and perpetually blue-tinted.

🖤 Final Thoughts

These aren’t the bloodiest, scariest, or most high-budget horror movies — but they’re the ones that shaped my spooky-season comfort zone. They’re cozy in their chaos, cheesy in all the right ways, and proof that sometimes the best kind of fear comes with a side of nostalgia.

So grab a blanket, dim the lights, and start your own “questioning my life choices” marathon.
Just… maybe don’t fall asleep with the windows open.

Download The List Today